How to reply to a positive review with criticism (with example)

Thank them for the good bits and answer the 'but' without sounding defensive

To reply to a positive review with criticism ("loved it, but…") you need to do two things in a few lines: thank them for something specific they enjoyed, and acknowledge the complaint without excuses. Skipping the "but" is the most common mistake, and it's exactly what prospective customers notice.

Portada: «Todo genial, pero…», cómo responder a la pega de una reseña buena. Respuesta antes y después.

Why the "but" matters

A four-star review saying "great food, but we waited 40 minutes for our mains" is gold: the customer came, enjoyed it and gave you free feedback. Anyone reading it sees that too. Replying only "thanks for the stars!" suggests you didn't read it, or didn't care.

Before and after

Take a restaurant in Valencia and the example review from Marta above.

Respuesta mala de ejemplo: muchas gracias por tus estrellas, esperamos verte pronto. Ignora la pega del cliente.

The "before" reply is polite but empty: it would fit any review for any business. The "after" reply uses her name, mentions the rice, agrees about the wait and says what changed. Three sentences, and the next reader sees a place that takes details seriously.

Respuesta buena de ejemplo: agradece el arroz, da la razón sobre la espera y explica que se ha reforzado el turno de cocina.

1. Thank them for something specific

Start with what they liked, and be precise: the dish, a member of staff, the terrace. That detail proves you read the whole review, not just the rating.

2. Own the complaint, no excuses

"We were really busy" or "nobody else has mentioned it" sound defensive even when true. Just acknowledge it: "You're right about the mains." If it's a matter of taste, thank them for the honesty and leave it there.

3. Say what's changed, if anything has

If you've made a change, say so in one line. If not, don't invent one: "thanks for letting us know, we've shared it with the team" is honest and enough. Don't offer anything in return for editing the review; Google's policies don't allow it.

For more ideas, see mistakes when replying to positive reviews and how to reply to a 3-star review.

Checklist

Checklist para responder la pega: su nombre, algo concreto, reconocer sin excusas, explicar cambios e invitar a volver sin regalos.

Saving time

Writing every reply with this much care takes time. HolaRevi drafts AI replies that mention the specifics of each review, in the reviewer's language and your brand tone, and you can check them before they go live. See the plans.


This article expands one of our Instagram carousels. Follow @holarevi for more tips on reviews and reputation.

Frequently asked questions

Should I reply to the negative part of a 4 or 5-star review?

Yes. It's what prospective customers look at, and ignoring it suggests you didn't read it. One sentence acknowledging it without excuses is enough, plus another explaining what's changed if that's true. The rest of the reply can thank them for what they enjoyed.

Can I offer a discount to a customer who mentioned a problem?

You can invite them back, but never offer anything in exchange for changing or removing the review: Google's policies forbid it. An honest, specific reply usually works better than a freebie, keeps the conversation public and transparent, and doesn't put your profile at risk.