How to reply to a review that isn't true (without calling anyone a liar)

Three steps and two examples for answering a mistaken or exaggerated review calmly

The best way to reply to a review that isn't true is not to accuse anyone: assume it might be a mistake, give one fact anyone can check, and offer to sort it out privately. People reading your reply can't tell who's right, but they can tell who stays calm.

Portada: Contestar «eso es mentira» te sale caro. Cómo responder una reseña que cuenta algo que no pasó, sin acusar a nadie.

Why "that's a lie" hurts you even when you're right

When a review mentions a dish you don't serve or a day you were closed, the instinct is to write "that's false". Everyone else just sees two clashing stories and a defensive owner. An angry reply turns a misunderstanding into a public argument that stays on your profile.

It happens more than you'd think. In 2024 a Spanish newspaper told the story of O Tranquilo, a restaurant near Vigo founded in 1952: a customer mixed it up with another place and criticised a squid dish that wasn't on its menu. She later admitted the mistake, but the review stayed up on Tripadvisor. What you can control is the reply that sits under it.

Ejemplo de respuesta que no conviene: «Eso es totalmente falso. Ese día ni abrimos. Deje de inventarse cosas».

1. Assume it could be a mistake

People confuse places with similar names, get the date wrong or exaggerate when they're annoyed. Starting from there changes your tone: you're no longer calling someone out, you're trying to work out what happened. "We're a bit puzzled, as we don't serve that dish – could it have been the café across the road?" gives them an easy way to correct it.

2. Give a fact, not an adjective

"Fake" or "unfair" is your opinion. "We're closed on Tuesdays" or "that dish isn't on our menu" is something anyone can check. Just don't share personal details about the customer or their visit.

Ejemplo de respuesta que sí ayuda: saluda a Marta, explica que ese martes el local cerraba por descanso, pregunta si fue otro local e invita a escribir.

3. Leave the door open

End by offering to talk privately: "Drop us a message and we'll look into it." Someone who got it wrong is far more likely to edit a review when they haven't been embarrassed in public.

If they were never a customer, report it separately

Replying and reporting aren't mutually exclusive. Google Maps' content policy doesn't allow content that isn't based on a real experience, or content affected by a conflict of interest, such as a competitor or former employee. Report it from your Business Profile and keep screenshots.

Checklist antes de publicar: sin decir mentira ni falso, un dato concreto, tono tranquilo, invitación a hablar en privado y denunciarla aparte si no fue cliente.

Checklist before you publish

How HolaRevi helps

HolaRevi drafts an AI reply to every review in the customer's language and your brand tone, and you can keep negative reviews on manual approval so you edit them before they go live. See the plans.


This article expands one of our Instagram carousels. Follow @holarevi for more tips on reviews and reputation.

Frequently asked questions

What if a customer reviewed the wrong restaurant?

Reply calmly with the fact that shows it, such as the dish not being on your menu, and politely ask whether it might have been another place. Offer to talk privately. Customers often edit or remove the review themselves when nobody has embarrassed them.

Can I get Google to remove a review that isn't true?

Google won't remove a review just because it's negative or you disagree. You can report it if it breaks the content policy, for example if it isn't based on a real experience or involves a conflict of interest.