How to respond to a 3 star review (with 8 examples)

Mixed reviews are your most useful feedback: answer them so the customer wants to come back.

Knowing how to respond to a 3 star review comes down to four moves: thank them for what they liked, quoting it back; own what went wrong without excuses; say what you are changing; and invite them back or to get in touch. A mixed review is the most useful feedback you will get, because it tells you what works and what does not in one go. It is also the one most businesses answer worst, with a bland "thanks for your feedback" or a defensive paragraph.

Below you will find the structure, eight example replies by type of complaint and sector, and what to avoid, including what Google's policies say about asking someone to change their rating.

Why a mixed review deserves your best reply

A one-star review is sometimes a vent and a five-star review is a pat on the back. A three-star review is usually a customer who came in, enjoyed specific things and left with one specific problem. That is a free summary of your business.

Why a mixed review deserves your best reply

Photo by Mihai Vlasceanu on Pexels

It also has two audiences. The first is the reviewer: Google's help centre says the reviewer is notified when you reply and that customers can update their review after reading your response. You do not need to ask; a good reply is the best reason for them to come back and, if they choose, revise it. The second audience is everyone checking your profile before deciding where to go. A mixed review answered well shows you listen and fix things.

If the review is genuinely negative (one or two stars, anger, accusations), the approach is different; see our guide on how to respond to negative Google reviews.

A four-step structure for 3 star review replies

A four-step structure for 3 star review replies

Photo by Max Vakhtbovych on Pexels

1. Thank them for the good bits, specifically

Skip "thanks for your review". Repeat what they liked in their words: "the Sunday roast", "how patient Priya was with the kids". It proves you read it and reinforces the positive for anyone else reading.

2. Acknowledge the problem without excuses

Name it plainly: "the 40-minute wait for mains". Google's tips for writing better review replies say to admit mistakes that were made, but not to take responsibility for things outside your control, to apologise where appropriate, and never to attack the reviewer. Watch out for "sorry, but": "sorry about the wait, but it was Saturday" cancels the apology.

3. Say what you are changing

This is the step almost everyone skips. One sentence is enough: "we have added a second chef on weekends". If nothing will change (your prices, say), explain why honestly, without sounding put out.

4. Invite them back or offline

End with a specific invitation and, where needed, a direct channel such as the shop's email or phone. Sign with your name or initials, as Google recommends, and keep it short: the same page notes that long replies can overwhelm customers.

Example replies by type of complaint

Swap in your own details. The point is that each reply clearly answers that review, not every review.

Waiting time

Tapas bar in Manchester. Review: "Food was brilliant, but it took nearly half an hour to get the bill."

Hi Emma, glad the food hit the spot. You're right about the bill; half an hour is too long. From this week one of the team handles payments only during peak hours. Hope to see you again soon. Tom, manager

Dental practice in Bristol. Review: "The dentist explained everything clearly, but I waited 25 minutes past my appointment."

Thank you, James, for mentioning Dr Shah's explanations. Sorry about the wait: an emergency ran over and we didn't let you know, which is the part we got wrong. We now text patients when we're running more than 15 minutes late. The practice team

Price

Seafood restaurant in Brighton. Review: "Great fish, but felt pricey for the portion size."

Thanks, Sophie. We buy from the day boats and we're pleased it showed. Fair point on portions: we've added smaller plates of our most popular dishes so you can try more without the bill climbing. Hope you'll give them a go. Dan

Garage in Leicester. Review: "Car runs perfectly now, but the final bill was higher than the quote."

Hi Mark, glad the car's running well. You're right to raise the bill: we found a worn part and should have called you before replacing it. We won't do any extra work without your OK from now on. Happy to go through the invoice with you. The workshop team

Noise

Café in Leeds. Review: "Lovely coffee, but so loud I couldn't hear my friend."

Thanks, Hannah. Pleased you enjoyed the coffee. Mid-morning does get loud. We've turned the music down and kept the back room for quieter chats. After 3pm it's much calmer if you fancy another visit. Ellie

Service

Hair salon in Glasgow. Review: "Love the cut, but the welcome at reception was a bit cold."

Thank you, Fiona, really glad you love the cut. Sorry the welcome fell short; we want you to feel at home from the moment you walk in, and we've talked it through as a team. See you next time. Kirsty

Product

Bakery in York. Review: "Cheesecake was amazing. The croissant was a bit dry."

Thanks, Oliver, we'll take the cheesecake praise. You're right about the croissant: the afternoon batch had been out too long. We now bake a second batch at 3pm. Let us know what you think next time. The bakery team

Quick reference

Complaint What to acknowledge What to tell them
Waiting The actual time, no excuses What you have reorganised
Price Their view, without arguing Lighter options or why it costs what it does
Noise When or where it happens Music, quieter areas, calmer times
Service How they felt That you have discussed it with the team
Product The specific fault The change in your process

What not to do

What not to do

Photo by Furkan Tumer on Pexels

For more pitfalls, read mistakes when replying to negative reviews.

Where to start today

  1. Filter your Google Business Profile for unanswered three-star reviews, including older ones.
  2. Note the complaint in each. If one keeps coming up, that is your priority.
  3. Make one real change for the most common complaint, however small.
  4. Reply using the four steps and sign with your name.

If you have more reviews than time, HolaRevi drafts AI replies that mention the specific details in each review, in your tone and in the reviewer's language. You choose whether replies publish automatically by star rating or wait for you to approve or edit them, and you can answer older reviews too. See the plans.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 3 star review good or bad?

Neither, really. It usually means a decent experience with one specific problem, which is why it is so useful: it tells you what works and what does not in a single review. Do not treat it as an attack or as a pass. Thank them for the positives, acknowledge what went wrong and explain what you are changing.

Can I ask a customer to change their 3 star review?

Google's policies ban offering incentives such as discounts or free items for changing or removing a review, and ban discouraging negative reviews. The sensible approach is not to ask. Fix the issue and reply well instead; Google notifies reviewers when you respond, and they can update their review if they choose.

Should I apologise in a reply to a 3 star review?

Apologise for the specific thing that went wrong, if it was down to you, and keep it to one sentence. Google advises admitting mistakes but not taking responsibility for things outside your control. A vague 'sorry for any inconvenience' sounds scripted, while 'sorry the bill took half an hour' shows you actually read the review.